States should think twice before creating strategic crypto reserves, as New Hampshire has done. That state's lawmakers placed a dubious bet using public funds on a shady and risky product. If they lose, so will taxpayers and others.
The crypto industry's massive political spending in 2024 has bought many politicians willing to agree to whatever light-touch regulations they seek. This has sparked interest in crypto among some investors, who see this as a green light to invest in crypto's vaunted claims of innovation.
But the industry's systemic problems that caused the 2022 crypto market crash, wiping out $2 trillion in investor funds, are still present. Fraud, doubledealing, backroom deals, risky loans, poor management, money laundering, daily hacks and other problems are the rule in crypto markets, not the exception.
Many if not most people have lost money on their crypto investments. Many of the tens of thousands of crypto tokens introduced annually go to "zero" in value. Crypto markets are full of fake trading orchestrated by insiders to boost tokens or prices artificially and cheat unsuspecting investors. Last year, consumers reported $9.3 billion in losses due to cryptorelated financial crime to the FBI -- a huge increase but likely an undercount, given that many victims fail to report out of shame.
People are also reading... A look inside the new $16M affordable apartment building on Jackson Street La Crosse police abandon policy that led to federal lawsuit The Rookery opens in former Eagles Nest location - Steve Cahalan Holmen man charged with downloading child pornography and child erotica Man in critical condition after Jackson County deputy shoots him after chase New police chief to take over Arcadia Police Department after mass resignations 'Person of interest' sought by police after shooting Thursday in La Crosse Onalaska sets tone for cannabis restrictions in La Crosse County Travis J. Jensen Crumbl Cookies store to open in late May - Steve Cahalan La Crosse man charged with stabbing man in neck, narcotics possession La Crosse to open shelters, ramps ahead of severe storm alert City green lights Mayo Clinic plan to replace aging Sparta hospital Wisconsin veterans voice concerns as Trump's VA cuts loom Sparta Area School District closed Tuesday due to utility outage
So why would anyone suggest it's wise to use public funds to set aside crypto assets as "reserves"? It's like stockpiling poker chips and hoping whoever's gambling with them wins big.
The main argument for a crypto reserve is that the numbers, allegedly, will go up. Big crypto assets such as bitcoin will supposedly appreciate over time, which boosters claim makes them a hedge against inflation or market turmoil.
But crypto prices, including bitcoin, tend to correlate with traditional financial markets. Many crypto assets are highly volatile, dropping in value dramatically with little warning, not to mention all the fraud. How does all that risk square with governments' responsibility to manage public funds prudently for the long term? It doesn't.
Despite hype about crypto markets booming, trading activity is still relatively low. Most people are wary of crypto. For big crypto investors (called "whales") who are sitting on big piles of bitcoin, this means they might be rich on paper, but they can't sell. Doing so with low demand would flood the market, depressing prices and devaluing their holdings.
If state governments become guaranteed buyers, these big whales overnight have a great way to cash out. Good for them, perhaps, but I doubt it's good for the rest of us.
Ironically, the mostly conservative voices pushing for a crypto reserve have historically hated similar ideas. These voices have criticized programs such as the strategic petroleum reserve, arguing that they interfere with the free market. At least with a petroleum or grain reserve, you are stockpiling something useful. Even after 15 years, finding real uses for crypto beyond speculative gambling and illicit finance is hard.
Despite crypto's deep-seated problems, the industry's aggressive influence-peddling, promotion and risky products will likely create another bubble that bursts, harming more people this time. States should resist the crypto fear of missing out, be responsible stewards of public funds and decline risky bets on crypto.
Hays is associate director for crypto and fintech at Americans for Financial Reform. He wrote this for InsideSources.com.
It's like stockpiling poker chips and hoping whoever's gambling with them wins big.
Love 0 Funny 0 Wow 0 Sad 0 Angry 0
Be the first to know
Get local news delivered to your inbox!
Sign up! * I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.